How to Calculate a Trading Account's Return: Formula and Common Mistakes
“How much has this account actually earned?” The common shortcut, current balance minus the initial deposit, stops answering that question as soon as you add or withdraw money. Here is how to separate trading profit from cash flows on an MT4/MT5 account, why percentages become misleading, and which mistakes can make a losing strategy look profitable.
The simple formula and why it misleads
The intuitive calculation is (current balance − initial deposit) / initial deposit × 100%. It works only while there are no further deposits or withdrawals. Suppose you deposit $1,000, the account grows to $1,500, and you withdraw $400. The remaining balance is $1,100. The shortcut reports 10%, although the account earned $500: 50% of the original deposit. Every cash flow changes the picture.
Separate trading profit from cash flows
The key is to subtract non-trading cash flows from the change in balance. For deposits and withdrawals, the reconciliation is:
Identify other non-trading broker adjustments separately as well. A percentage return also needs a clearly defined capital base. When money enters or leaves during the period, a time-weighted method or a method that weights capital by the time it was invested is more informative than dividing by the current balance. Dividing cash-flow-adjusted profit by the opening balance is a simple reference figure, but it does not fully account for the timing of later deposits.
Choosing the period and the result
- Day, week, or month: use the opening balance for that period as the reference, and isolate trading profit within the same dates.
- Floating versus realised: profit on open positions, reflected in the difference between balance and equity, can disappear before the positions close. Show closed-trade performance and floating P/L separately.
- Commission and swap: these are trading costs. A trade profitable on price alone may lose money after entry commission and overnight financing.
Common return-calculation mistakes
| Mistake | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Dividing by the current balance rather than the relevant capital base | Deposits distort the percentage |
| Ignoring deposits and withdrawals | A deposit looks like profit; a withdrawal looks like a loss |
| Treating floating profit as realised | The reported return may vanish on a reversal |
| Ignoring swap and commission | A losing strategy can appear profitable |
| Reporting return without drawdown | High returns conceal the risk taken to earn them |
A return number without drawdown says little about the strategy. A monthly gain of 30% with a 50% drawdown carries a very different risk from 10% with an 8% drawdown. Assess profit and risk together, as described in the risk-management guide.
How FilMonitor presents this
FilMonitor Pro shows account results for the day, week, and month with cash-flow adjustments, rather than treating every balance change as trading profit. Entry commissions are accounted for separately from transfers so they are not mistaken for deposits or withdrawals. Floating P/L is displayed separately from realised results, alongside drawdown. Free includes basic account metrics and a daily summary; 30 days of Pro 1 are available after signup confirmation.
Checklist for a meaningful account return
- Reconcile balance changes with deposits, withdrawals, and other non-trading adjustments.
- State the capital base and calculation method behind a percentage.
- Keep floating and realised profit separate.
- Include swap and commission in the trading result.
- Always assess return alongside drawdown.